介入放射学工作人员个人剂量监测评价方法的比较分析

Comparative analysis of individual dose monitoring and evaluation methods for interventional radiology workers

  • 摘要:
    目的 比较不同个人剂量监测评价方法对介入放射学工作人员个人剂量监测结果的影响,为完善介入放射学工作人员个人剂量监测工作提供科学依据。
    方法 采用回顾性横断面研究,分析云南省疾病预防控制中心职业健康与放射卫生所放射性检测实验室2021—2024年监测的2 109人次介入放射学工作人员的个人剂量监测数据,每个监测周期为3个月。方法1采用0.1Ho(铅围裙外个人剂量当量)计算周期个人剂量当量Hp(10)适用于体表下10 mm 深处的器官或组织的监测,在特定条件下用于有效剂量评价。以下简称Hp(10);方法2采用0.790Hu(铅围裙内个人剂量当量)+0.051Ho计算Hp(10);方法3在Ho≥5Hu时,采用0.790Hu+0.051Ho计算Hp(10),其他情况下均使用Hu作为Hp(10)。比较3种方法的有效监测率Hp(10)≥最低探测水平的人次占比和Hp(10)水平。多组间比较采用非参数Kruskal-Wallis H检验,两两比较采用Dunn检验(Bonferroni校正)。
    结果 方法1、方法2、方法3的有效监测率分别为49.36%、98.25%和97.72%,3种方法的Hp(10)中位数分别为0.04、0.11和0.13 mSv。多组间比较结果显示,不同评价方法计算出的Hp(10)差异有统计学意义(H=833.897,P<0.01);两两比较结果显示,各方法间Hp(10)的差异均有统计学意义(方法1对方法2:Z=−23.829;方法1对方法3:Z=−28.029;方法2对方法3:Z=−5.159,均P<0.01)。
    结论 不同监测评价方法对介入放射学工作人员个人剂量监测结果有明显影响,建议在实际工作中选用适宜的监测评价方法,以提升监测结果的可靠性。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective To compare the effects of different monitoring and evaluation methods on individual dose monitoring results among interventional radiology workers and establish a scientific basis for improving individual dose monitoring strategies in this population.
    Methods This was a retrospective cross-sectional study. The study analyzed individual dose monitoring data of 2109 person-times of interventional radiology workers monitored by Radioactive Testing Laboratory, Department of Occupational and Radiological Health, Yunnan Center for Disease Control and Prevention from 2021 to 2024, with each monitoring cycle lasting three months. Method 1 calculated the periodic individual dose equivalent Hp(10) ( Hp(10) refers to the monitoring of organs or tissues at a depth of 10 mm below the body surface and is used for effective dose assessment under specific conditions; hereinafter referred to as Hp(10)) using 0.1Ho (individual dose equivalent outside the lead apron). Method 2 calculated Hp(10) as 0.790Hu (individual dose equivalent under the lead apron)+0.051Ho. For Method 3, 0.790Hu+0.051Ho was adopted to calculate Hp(10) when Ho≥5Hu; under other circumstances, Hu was directly taken as Hp(10). The effective monitoring rate (the proportion of person-times with Hp(10) ≥ minimum detectable level) and Hp(10) levels of the three methods were compared. The non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis H test was used for multi-group comparison, and Dunn′s test (with Bonferroni correction) was adopted for pairwise comparisons.
    Results The effective monitoring rates for Methods 1, 2, and 3 were 49.36%, 98.25%, and 97.72%, respectively, and their median Hp(10) values were 0.04, 0.11, and 0.13 mSv, respectively. The multi-group comparison showed statistically significant difference in Hp(10) calculated by different evaluation methods (H=833.897, P<0.01). Pairwise comparisons further revealed statistically significant differences in Hp(10) between all pairs of methods (Method 1 vs. Method 2: Z=−23.829; Method 1 vs. Method 3: Z=−28.029; Method 2 vs. Method 3: Z=−5.159; all P<0.01).
    Conclusions Different monitoring and evaluation methods can substantially affect the individual dose monitoring results of interventional radiology workers. Therefore, the selection of appropriate monitoring and evaluation methods in routine practice is recommended to improve the reliability of monitoring results.

     

/

返回文章
返回